* docs: design spec for #7799 outdated-notice redesign Per-pad first-author gating, dismissable gritter, minor-or-more rule, drop vulnerable UI. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs: implementation plan for #7799 outdated-notice redesign 12 bite-sized tasks, TDD-first where applicable; closes the spec end-to-end. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat(updater): add isMinorOrMoreBehind, drop major/vulnerable helpers Adds isMinorOrMoreBehind(current, latest) which returns true only when the latest release is at least one minor version ahead (patch-only deltas return false). Removes isMajorBehind, parseVulnerableBelow, and isVulnerable from versionCompare.ts — callers in updateStatus.ts, VersionChecker.ts, and index.ts will be updated in subsequent tasks. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * refactor(updater): drop vulnerable-below directive and state field Remove VulnerableBelowDirective type, UpdateState.vulnerableBelow field, and all related scraping/checking logic (parseVulnerableBelow, isVulnerable imports). Clean up Notifier, OpenAPI schema, and all test fixtures to match. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * refactor(updater): drop residual EmailSendLog vulnerable fields Remove `vulnerableAt` and `vulnerableNewReleaseTag` from the `EmailSendLog` interface, `EMPTY_STATE`, and the `isValidEmail` validator — these backed the removed `vulnerable`/`vulnerable-new-release` email kinds and are now dead code. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat(updater): add firstAuthorOf helper Export firstAuthorOf() from updateStatus.ts — finds the lowest-numbered author attrib in a pad's pool, skipping empty-string placeholders. Covered by 6 vitest cases in tests/backend-new/specs/hooks/express/. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat(updater): add resolveRequestAuthor helper for HTTP GET Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat(updater): pad-aware /api/version-status with first-author gating Replace global badge cache with a per-(padId, authorId) LRU cache. The new response shape is {outdated: 'minor' | null, isFirstAuthor: boolean}; the old 'severe'/'vulnerable' enum is dropped entirely. computeOutdated now resolves the pad's first author and compares it against the session author before returning outdated:'minor', so the notice is only shown to the person who created the pad. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(updater): switch isSevere signal from major-only to minor-or-more behind Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(updater): end-to-end coverage for /api/version-status Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(openapi): /api/version-status pad-aware shape and gating Add the /api/version-status GET operation to the admin OpenAPI spec with the new pad-aware response shape: outdated enum reduced to [minor]|null, isFirstAuthor boolean, and an optional padId query param. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore(pad): remove unused #version-badge template and CSS * feat(pad): replace persistent badge with first-author outdated gritter Renames pad_version_badge.ts → pad_outdated_notice.ts and rewrites it as a fire-and-forget gritter notice that only shows when the API reports outdated=minor AND the current user is the pad's first author. Wires the new maybeShowOutdatedNotice() call into pad.ts immediately after showPrivacyBannerIfEnabled(). Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(pad): playwright coverage for outdated notice gritter Six Playwright specs exercise maybeShowOutdatedNotice: null response, isFirstAuthor:false guard, positive appearance + text, X-dismiss, 500 server error tolerance, and 8 s auto-fade. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(pad): outdated-notice redesign + drop vulnerable-below docs Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore(test): remove stale specs for deleted #version-badge surface Delete the GET /api/version-status describe block from the legacy mocha spec (asserted outdated:null and outdated:'severe' — both no longer match the new response shape). The new vitest spec at tests/backend-new/specs/hooks/express/updateStatus.test.ts covers this surface comprehensively. Delete src/tests/frontend-new/specs/pad-version-badge.spec.ts entirely: all three tests reference the #version-badge DOM element removed in Task 8 and stub 'severe'/'vulnerable' enum values that no longer exist. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore: clean stale references to vulnerable/severe in types, emails, docs - Remove OutdatedLevel type (null|'severe') from types.ts — no consumers remain after the badge redesign removed the severe tier. - Fix Notifier severe-email body: was "more than one major release behind" but isSevere now fires on minor-or-more, so update to "at least one minor release behind the latest published version". - Drop "vulnerability directives" from the /admin/update/status OpenAPI description; replace with the actual response fields. - Remove stale vulnerableBelow field from UpdateStatusPayload in admin/src/store/store.ts — server no longer sends it. - Fix docs/admin/updates.md: "pad-side badge" → "pad-side notice". Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
18 KiB
Etherpad updates
Etherpad ships with a built-in update subsystem.
- Tier 1 (notify) — default. A banner appears in the admin UI when a new release is available, and pad users see a dismissable gritter notification if the running version is at least one minor version behind the latest release. No execution.
- Tier 2 (manual click) — admins on a git install can click "Apply update" at
/admin/update. Etherpad drains active sessions, runsgit fetch / checkout / pnpm install / pnpm run build:ui, and exits with code 75 so a process supervisor restarts it on the new version. Auto-rolls back on failure. - Tier 3 (auto with grace window) — opt-in. On a git install, a newly detected release transitions execution state to
scheduledand is applied afterpreApplyGraceMinutes. During the grace window,/admin/updateshows a live countdown plus Cancel and Apply now buttons; an admin email (ifadminEmailis set) fires once per scheduled tag. - Tier 4 (autonomous in maintenance window) — opt-in. Tier 3 +
updates.maintenanceWindowis required; the scheduler only fires while the wall clock is inside the configured window. Updates detected outside the window queue for the next opening.
Settings
In settings.json:
{
"updates": {
"tier": "notify",
"source": "github",
"channel": "stable",
"installMethod": "auto",
"checkIntervalHours": 6,
"githubRepo": "ether/etherpad",
"requireAdminForStatus": false,
// Tier 2+ knobs (only meaningful at tier "manual" or higher):
"preApplyGraceMinutes": 0,
"drainSeconds": 60,
"rollbackHealthCheckSeconds": 60,
"diskSpaceMinMB": 500,
"requireSignature": false,
"trustedKeysPath": null
},
"adminEmail": null
}
| Setting | Default | Notes |
|---|---|---|
updates.tier |
"notify" |
One of "off", "notify", "manual", "auto", "autonomous". Higher tiers are silently downgraded if the install method does not allow them. PR 1 only honors "notify" and "off". |
updates.source |
"github" |
Reserved for future alternative sources. Only "github" is implemented. |
updates.channel |
"stable" |
Reserved. Stable releases only. |
updates.installMethod |
"auto" |
One of "auto", "git", "docker", "npm", "managed". Auto-detects via filesystem heuristics. Set explicitly to override. |
updates.checkIntervalHours |
6 |
How often to poll GitHub Releases. |
updates.githubRepo |
"ether/etherpad" |
Override for forks. |
updates.requireAdminForStatus |
false |
Lock the /admin/update/status endpoint to authenticated admin sessions. Default false matches existing Etherpad behavior — /health already exposes releaseId publicly, and changelog data comes from a public GitHub release. Set true to hide the full update payload from non-admins without disabling the updater (tier: "off" is the heavier opt-out that removes the endpoints entirely). |
updates.preApplyGraceMinutes |
0 |
Tier 3 only. Wait this many minutes between detecting a new release and starting the drain so the admin can cancel via /admin/update. 0 applies immediately when allowed. Clamped to [0, 7*24*60] (one week). Has no effect at tier "manual". |
updates.drainSeconds |
60 |
How long to broadcast "restart imminent" announcements to active pads before exiting. T-60 / T-30 / T-10 broadcasts fire automatically at the matching offsets within this window. |
updates.rollbackHealthCheckSeconds |
60 |
After a fresh boot post-update, give /health this long to come up. If it doesn't, RollbackHandler restores the previous SHA. |
updates.diskSpaceMinMB |
500 |
Pre-flight refuses to start an update unless the install volume has at least this many MB free. |
updates.requireSignature |
false |
When true, refuse updates whose tag is not signed by a trusted key. Verification is done via git verify-tag <tag> against the user's GPG keyring. Default false because Etherpad's release process does not yet sign tags consistently — turning the check on by default would block every Tier 2 update. Set true if you run your own builds or have imported a fork's keys. |
updates.trustedKeysPath |
null |
Override the keyring location passed to git verify-tag via the $GNUPGHOME env var. Useful when the trusted keys live in a dedicated keyring outside the Etherpad user's home. Only meaningful when requireSignature: true. |
adminEmail |
null |
Top-level. Contact for admin notifications. Setting it enables the email nudges below. |
What "outdated" means
minor— the running server is at least one minor version behind the latest published release. Patch-only deltas (same major and minor, higher patch) do not fire the notice.
Email cadence (when adminEmail is set)
| Trigger | First send | Repeat |
|---|---|---|
| Outdated (minor or more behind) detected | Immediate | Monthly while still outdated |
| Up to date | No email | — |
If adminEmail is unset, the updater never sends mail. The admin UI banner and the pad-side notice still work without it.
PR 1 ships the cadence machinery but does not yet wire a real SMTP transport — emails are logged with (would send email) until a future PR adds the transport. The dedupe state still advances correctly so admins are not bombarded once SMTP is wired.
Pad-side notice
Pad users see no version information by default. A dismissable gritter notification appears only when:
- The running server is at least one minor version behind the latest published release (patch-only deltas do not fire), and
- The requesting user is the first author of the pad.
The notice auto-fades after 8 seconds and can be dismissed immediately. The public endpoint /api/version-status accepts an optional ?padId=<id> query parameter and returns {outdated: "minor" | null, isFirstAuthor: boolean} — it never leaks the running version, so attackers do not gain a fingerprint vector. Results are cached per (padId, authorId) for 60 seconds.
Disabling everything
Set updates.tier to "off". No HTTP request will leave the instance and no banner or badge will render.
Privacy
The version check sends no telemetry. Etherpad fetches the public GitHub Releases API (api.github.com/repos/<repo>/releases/latest) with If-None-Match to be cache-friendly. The only metadata GitHub sees is the same as any other GitHub API client — your IP and a User-Agent: etherpad-self-update header. No instance ID, no version, no identifiers travel upstream.
How install method is detected
updates.installMethod defaults to "auto", which uses these heuristics in order:
/.dockerenvexists →"docker"..git/directory present and the install root is writable →"git".package-lock.jsonpresent and writable →"npm".- Otherwise →
"managed".
Set the value explicitly if the heuristics get it wrong (e.g., a docker container that bind-mounts a writable git checkout).
In PR 1 (notify only) the install method does not change behavior — every install method gets the banner. From PR 2 onward the install method gates whether the manual-click and automatic tiers can run; only "git" is initially supported for write tiers.
Tier 2 — manual click
Tier 2 is opt-in. To enable: set updates.tier: "manual" and ensure your install was deployed via git (not docker / npm / managed package).
Process supervisor is required
Etherpad applies an update by exiting with code 75 so a process supervisor restarts it. Without a supervisor the instance simply exits and stays down. Common supervisor setups:
- systemd: add
Restart=on-failure+RestartSec=5to your unit file. - pm2: the default behaviour restarts on exit.
- docker: add
--restart=unless-stopped(Tier 2 itself is not supported on docker installs anyway, but if you wrap your own image around a git checkout this applies).
What clicking "Apply update" does
- Lock acquire —
var/update.lock(PID-based, stale locks reaped automatically). - Pre-flight checks — install method writable, working tree clean, free disk ≥
diskSpaceMinMB,pnpmonPATH, target tag exists at the configured remote, signature verifies (ifrequireSignature: true). On failure, state goes topreflight-failedwith a typed reason; the admin sees a banner and clicks Acknowledge to clear it. No filesystem mutation has happened — nothing to roll back. - Drain —
drainSecondswindow during which T-60 / T-30 / T-10 announcements broadcast to every connected pad and new socket connections are refused. Click Cancel during this window to abort cleanly. - Execute —
git fetch --tags origin,git checkout <tag>,pnpm install --frozen-lockfile,pnpm run build:ui. Output streams tovar/log/update.log(rotated 10 MB × 5). - Exit 75 — the supervisor restarts on the new version.
- Health check — RollbackHandler arms a
rollbackHealthCheckSecondstimer at boot. When/healthresponds 200 (i.e., Etherpad reaches theRUNNINGstate) the timer cancels and the state lands onverified.
Failure modes
| What went wrong | Resulting state | Admin action |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-flight check fails | preflight-failed |
Click Acknowledge after fixing the underlying issue (free up disk, clean working tree, etc.). |
git fetch / git checkout fails mid-flow |
rolled-back |
Informational. The working tree is back where it started; click Acknowledge to clear. |
pnpm install or pnpm run build:ui fails |
rolled-back |
Same as above. The lockfile and SHA are restored. |
/health doesn't come up within rollbackHealthCheckSeconds |
rolled-back |
Same — RollbackHandler restores the previous SHA + lockfile and exits 75 again. |
The new version crashes at boot more than twice (bootCount > 2) |
rolled-back |
Crash-loop guard kicks in regardless of the health-check timer. |
Rollback itself fails (e.g., pnpm install errors restoring old lockfile) |
rollback-failed |
Manual intervention required. The admin banner switches to a strong red alert. Restore the install by hand, then click Acknowledge to clear the lock and re-allow Tier 2 attempts. |
Endpoints
All Tier 2 endpoints require an authenticated admin session (is_admin: true) regardless of requireAdminForStatus.
POST /admin/update/apply— start an apply. Returns202 {accepted, drainEndsAt}once the drain begins. Body unused.POST /admin/update/cancel— cancel during pre-flight or drain. Returns409once the executor has begun mutating the filesystem (state machine guarantees we either complete or roll back from there).POST /admin/update/acknowledge— clear a terminalpreflight-failed/rolled-back/rollback-failedstate back toidle.GET /admin/update/log— tail the last 200 lines ofvar/log/update.log. Plain text. Used by the in-progress UI.
Signature verification
Default off. Etherpad releases are not yet consistently signed; turning verification on by default would block every Tier 2 update. To enable:
"updates": {
"requireSignature": true,
"trustedKeysPath": "/srv/etherpad/keys" // optional — defaults to the OS user keyring
}
The check shells out to git verify-tag <tag>. The keyring at trustedKeysPath is passed to git via GNUPGHOME. If trustedKeysPath is null (default), the OS user's default keyring is used.
Docker-friendly update flows (future work)
Tier 2 deliberately refuses to apply on installMethod: "docker" because in-container git fetch / pnpm install / build:ui doesn't survive a container restart — the orchestrator brings the container back up on the same image tag and the work is lost. Docker installs stay on Tier 1 (banner + version status) for now.
Tier 3 — auto with grace window
Tier 3 builds on Tier 2 by scheduling the apply automatically when a new release is detected. The same git fetch / checkout / pnpm install / build:ui / exit 75 pipeline runs — only the trigger changes.
To enable, on a git install: set updates.tier: "auto" and (optionally) updates.preApplyGraceMinutes to the grace duration you want.
What happens when a new release lands
- The periodic version checker (
updates.checkIntervalHours) hits GitHub Releases. - If
policy.canAutois true (install is git, no terminalrollback-failedstate, tier is"auto"or"autonomous"), the scheduler transitionsexecution.statustoscheduledwithscheduledFor = now + preApplyGraceMinutes. - The schedule is persisted to
var/update-state.json, so an Etherpad restart inside the grace window rehydrates the timer rather than losing the schedule. /admin/updateshows a live countdown panel plus two buttons:- Cancel —
POST /admin/update/cancelreturns the state toidleand drops the in-process timer. - Apply now —
POST /admin/update/applyskips the remaining grace; the regular Tier 2 pipeline runs immediately.
- Cancel —
- When the timer fires, the scheduler runs the exact same pipeline as a manual Tier 2 click: pre-flight → drain → execute → exit 75.
Re-scheduling and stale state
- If a newer release tag appears while a schedule is pending, the scheduler re-arms the timer for the new tag. The
email.graceStartTagdedupe field guards against duplicategrace-startnotifications. - If
updates.tieris flipped back to"manual"or"notify"while a schedule is pending, the next periodic check cancels the schedule (state back toidle). rollback-faileddisables Tier 3 globally. The admin mustPOST /admin/update/acknowledge(or visit/admin/updateand click Acknowledge) before any further auto-schedules are armed. Tier 2 manual click stays available because the admin click is the intervention the terminal state requires.
Email (adminEmail set)
A single grace-start notification fires per scheduled tag:
[Etherpad] Auto-update scheduled for 2.7.2
with the scheduledFor timestamp. Etherpad core does not yet wire SMTP; the message logs as (would send email) until a future PR adds a transport. Cadence and dedupe still update correctly.
The right way to give docker admins an in-product Apply button is to delegate to the orchestrator rather than mutate the container. Two patterns to consider in a follow-up PR:
- Instructions-only. When the page detects
installMethod: dockerand a newer release exists, swap the policy-denial copy for actionable instructions (docker pull etherpad/etherpad:<tag>for plain docker;docker compose pull && docker compose up -dfor compose). Cheap, no new attack surface. - Deploy webhook. New setting
updates.dockerWebhook. When set, the Apply button on a docker install POSTs to the configured URL and trusts the orchestrator (Render / Railway / Fly / Portainer / Coolify / GitHub Actions — they all expose redeploy webhooks) to do the actual pull-and-recreate.
Direct Docker-socket access (mount /var/run/docker.sock into the container) is out of scope — anyone who escapes the Etherpad process via that socket gets root on the host. Admins who want fully autonomous docker updates should run Watchtower alongside Etherpad rather than bake equivalent privilege into Etherpad itself.
Tier 4 — autonomous in a maintenance window
Tier 4 layers a wall-clock window on top of Tier 3 so autonomous updates only run while it is safe to drain sessions (typically nightly).
To enable, on a git install:
{
"updates": {
"tier": "autonomous",
"preApplyGraceMinutes": 15,
"maintenanceWindow": { "start": "03:00", "end": "05:00", "tz": "local" }
}
}
start and end are 24-hour HH:MM wall-clock times in the configured tz ("local" or "utc"). end is exclusive; end < start denotes a cross-midnight window (22:00–02:00 runs from 22:00 through 01:59).
How the window gate works
evaluatePolicyreturnscanAutonomous: trueonly when the install isgit, tier is"autonomous", no terminalrollback-failedis set, andupdates.maintenanceWindowis set and parse-valid. Missing/malformed windows returncanAutonomous: falsewithpolicy.reasonequal tomaintenance-window-missing/maintenance-window-invalid, and the rest of the policy degrades to Tier 3 (canAuto: true). An admin banner surfaces the misconfiguration so the autonomous behavior is never silently disabled.- When the scheduler picks up a new release while
canAutonomous: true, it computesscheduledFor = now + preApplyGraceMinutes. If that timestamp falls outside the window, it is snapped forward to the next opening of the window. - When the timer fires, the scheduler re-checks the clock. If the window has already closed (long grace, clock skew, host suspend), the fire is deferred:
var/update-state.jsonis updated with a newscheduledForpointing at the next opening, the timer is re-armed, and the actual apply runs at the next valid moment.
DST and timezone notes
tz: "utc"is recommended for hosts running across DST boundaries — the window is interpreted against the same wall clock every day of the year.tz: "local"follows the host's local time. On DST spring-forward days, a window starting at a non-existent local time (e.g.02:30inAmerica/New_Yorkon the second Sunday of March) silently lands at the next valid wall-clock minute via the host JSDateconstructor's normalization. On fall-back days, the first occurrence of the wall-clock start time is used.- Cross-midnight windows (
end < start) span at most 24 hours; longer "windows" should be split into two settings, e.g. by running Tier 3 instead.
Admin UI
/admin/update shows a "Maintenance window" section when updates.tier == "autonomous":
- Configured: summary
HH:MM–HH:MM (tz)plus "Next window opens at …". - Not configured: a clear "Not configured" message and a top-of-page banner that links back to the page.
- During a deferred-grace schedule, the scheduled panel shows both the countdown to
scheduledForand an explanatory "Outside maintenance window. Update will start when the window opens at …" line.
Admins edit updates.maintenanceWindow via the parsed JSONC settings editor at /admin/settings. Saving an invalid shape is caught at boot — the warning is logged via the updater log4js category and the policy downgrades to Tier 3.