mirror of
https://github.com/ether/etherpad-lite.git
synced 2026-07-17 16:47:05 +00:00
8 commits
| Author | SHA1 | Message | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
04045fe532
|
Roll Node.js floor back to >= 24 (Active LTS) — closes #7779 (#7781)
* Roll Node.js floor back to >= 24 (Active LTS) Closes #7779. #7779 originally proposed bumping past the Node 25 stop-gap to Node 26. After re-checking the release schedule, the cleaner LTS target is actually Node 24: - Node 24 (Krypton) is currently in Active LTS, supported until ~May 2028. - Node 25 hit end-of-life on April 10 2026 — the floor merged in #7752 / #7749 / #7754 a day ago ships an already-EOL major. - Node 26 was released May 5 2026 and does not enter Active LTS until October 2026. So this PR reverts the Node 25 ratchet from those three PRs and lands on Node 24 — Etherpad's runtime floor stays on a supported LTS for the next ~2 years. Runtime / infra - `package.json` + `src/package.json`: `engines.node` `>=25.0.0` -> `>=24.0.0` - `bin/functions.sh`, `bin/installer.sh`, `bin/installer.ps1`: `REQUIRED_NODE_MAJOR` 25 -> 24 - `Dockerfile`: `node:25-alpine` -> `node:24-alpine` (both stages). Corepack-via-npm workaround is intentionally kept: it works on Node 24 (which still ships corepack) and on Node 25+ (which doesn't), so the same recipe survives the next LTS bump without churn. Comments reworded accordingly. - `snap/snapcraft.yaml`: pinned `NODE_VERSION` 25.9.0 -> 24.15.0; design notes + corepack comment adjusted - `packaging/nfpm.yaml`: `nodejs (>= 25)` -> `nodejs (>= 24)` in top-level depends + deb/rpm overrides - `packaging/bin/etherpad`: comment matches the new pin - `packaging/README.md`: build prereqs + apt install snippet point at `node_24.x`; the long-stale "engines.node floor is 20" line is fixed while we're here - `.github/workflows/*.yml`: setup-node `node-version` 25 -> 24 across every workflow; backend / frontend-admin / upgrade matrices `[25]` -> `[24]` - `.github/workflows/deb-package.yml`: `NODE_MAJOR=25` + `node_25.x` smoke-test installer -> 24 - `bin/plugins/lib/npmpublish.yml`: 25 -> 24 (template propagates to the ~80 ether/* plugins via update-plugins workflow) Docs - `README.md`: install one-liner + Requirements -> Node.js >= 24 - `doc/npm-trusted-publishing.md`: runner requirement -> Node 24 - `doc/plugins.md` / `doc/plugins.adoc`: plugin metadata example `engines.node` -> `">=24.0.0"` @types/node is left at ^25.8.0 — newer type definitions cover Node 24 runtime fine and avoid an unnecessary lockfile churn. Companion homepage one-liner change to follow on ether/ether.github.com. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(plugins): example engines.node = ">=22.0.0", not core's floor Plugin code is overwhelmingly ace-hook glue and rarely uses Node-version- specific APIs, so plugin engines.node should reflect the plugin's own requirements, not track core. Showing core's 24-floor in the example encouraged plugin authors to blindly copy a tighter pin than necessary and locked plugins out of being installable on older Etherpad/Node deployments. Use the most-recent Node LTS that has actually reached EOL (20 -> EOL April 2026) as the example floor, i.e. >=22. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> |
||
|
|
80c385e657
|
fix(deb): keep plugin_packages in-tree so admin-installed plugins can resolve ep_etherpad-lite (#7750)
* fix(deb): keep plugin_packages in-tree to fix admin-installed plugins
The .deb postinstall symlinked /opt/etherpad/src/plugin_packages to
/var/lib/etherpad/plugin_packages so the etherpad user could install
plugins under ProtectSystem=strict. Node.js resolves symlinks to their
realpath before walking node_modules, so a plugin installed via the
admin UI lived under /var/lib/etherpad/... and could no longer reach
the bundled ep_etherpad-lite in /opt/etherpad/node_modules. Every
require('ep_etherpad-lite/...') in installed plugins (and the matching
esbuild client-bundle build) failed with MODULE_NOT_FOUND, etherpad
exited, and the systemd unit restart-looped (ether/ep_comments_page#416).
Keep plugin_packages as a real in-tree directory, make it (and its
.versions/ subdir) group-writable by etherpad like node_modules already
is, and add it to ReadWritePaths= in the unit. Migrate the contents of
any pre-existing /var/lib/etherpad/plugin_packages symlink target back
in-tree on upgrade.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* ci(deb): update assertions for in-tree plugin_packages + cover migration
The previous assertions in packaging/test-local.sh and the deb-package
workflow checked that /opt/etherpad/src/plugin_packages was a symlink to
/var/lib/etherpad/plugin_packages -- the layout this PR is removing.
They would have failed under the new postinst.
- Assert plugin_packages is a real directory (not a symlink), owned by
group etherpad with mode 2775, matching node_modules.
- After the happy-path /health check, simulate a pre-fix install by
recreating the symlink with a marker plugin, re-run the postinst via
dpkg-reconfigure, and assert the marker payload was migrated back
in-tree and the symlink is gone. Locks in regression coverage for the
upgrade path (ether/ep_comments_page#416).
* ci(deb): add ep_layout_trip_wire fixture to gate plugin_packages layout
Layout assertions alone don't actually exercise the failure mode from
ether/ep_comments_page#416: they confirm /opt/etherpad/src/plugin_packages
is a real directory but never load a plugin whose index.js does
require('ep_etherpad-lite/...') from the on-disk realpath.
Ship a tiny test plugin under packaging/test-fixtures/ep_layout_trip_wire
that exercises the four require() patterns from the bug report (eejs,
Settings, log4js, pad_utils) and emits a marker line from
expressCreateServer. Both packaging/test-local.sh and the deb-package
workflow now stage it into plugin_packages/.versions/, wire up the
toplevel + node_modules symlinks live-plugin-manager would create,
list it in installed_plugins.json, restart etherpad, and assert:
* marker line appears in the journal (every require resolved), and
* no "Cannot find module 'ep_etherpad-lite" appears anywhere.
Verified locally that the fixture loads under the in-tree layout
(marker present) and fails under a symlinked-out-of-tree layout
(marker absent, MODULE_NOT_FOUND in the log) -- so the gate catches
the regression in both directions.
* fix(deb): clean up runtime plugin artifacts on purge
With plugin_packages now living under /opt/etherpad/src/plugin_packages,
admin-installed plugins land in dpkg-unmanaged paths (the .versions/
stage that live-plugin-manager populates plus matching ep_* symlinks
under src/node_modules/). dpkg --purge would leave them behind because
the manifest never recorded them.
In postremove's purge branch: explicitly rm -rf plugin_packages and any
runtime ep_* symlinks in node_modules, then rm -rf the whole APP_DIR
as belt-and-braces against other runtime drift. Verified in a sandbox
that a staged ep_runtime@1.0.0 + node_modules/ep_runtime symlink are
both gone after purge runs.
Add post-purge assertions to both packaging/test-local.sh and the
deb-package workflow: /opt/etherpad/src/plugin_packages and
/var/lib/etherpad must not exist after dpkg --purge.
Addresses Qodo PR #7750 review item 3 (\"Purge cleanup misses
plugins\", Reliability).
---------
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
||
|
|
9bdbb3ee95
|
fix(deb): bump nodejs Depends to >= 25; install Node 25 in smoke test (#7754)
Followup to #7752. That PR raised `src/package.json` engines.node to
>=25.0.0 (matching the workspace root) but missed three places that
still encoded the previous Node 22+ floor — so the deb-package CI
broke at sha
|
||
|
|
0a2facb3fc
|
ci(packaging): publish signed apt repository to etherpad.org/apt (closes #7610) (#7624)
* ci(packaging): publish signed apt repository to etherpad.org/apt (closes #7610) Adds an `apt-publish` workflow job that turns the existing `.deb` build artefacts into a signed apt repository hosted at: https://etherpad.org/apt/ End-user install on any Debian/Ubuntu/Mint: curl -fsSL https://etherpad.org/key.asc \ | sudo gpg --dearmor -o /usr/share/keyrings/etherpad.gpg echo "deb [signed-by=/usr/share/keyrings/etherpad.gpg] \ https://etherpad.org/apt stable main" \ | sudo tee /etc/apt/sources.list.d/etherpad.list sudo apt update && sudo apt install etherpad `apt upgrade` works going forward — every tagged release republishes the repo metadata. Change type: patch (CI/distribution; no production behaviour change). ## Why etherpad.org/apt and not ether.github.io/etherpad/apt ether/etherpad's GitHub Pages is already configured as build-from-workflow on `develop` with CNAME `docs.etherpad.org`, and a repo can only have one Pages source. Pushing the apt repo to a gh-pages branch would either be ignored (Pages is reading from the docs workflow) or, if Pages were switched to it, would kill the docs site. ether/ether.github.com is a separate Next.js site that already deploys etherpad.org and serves `public/` verbatim, so cross-pushing the apt repo into `public/apt/` lands it at the canonical Etherpad URL with no infrastructure conflicts. ## What this PR ships 1. `apt-publish` job in `.github/workflows/deb-package.yml`. Runs after `release` on `v*` tag pushes: - Clones ether/ether.github.com over SSH using a deploy key. - Wipes site/public/apt/ and rebuilds it from the per-arch .deb artefacts using apt-ftparchive. - Signs Release + emits InRelease/Release.gpg using the keypair in APT_SIGNING_KEY. - Drops key.asc into site/public/key.asc. - Asserts both per-arch .debs are present before the wipe takes effect — refuses to publish a partial / empty repo if an artefact is missing or renamed. - Commits and pushes to master; the site repo's existing build pipeline picks it up. 2. `packaging/apt/key.asc` — Etherpad APT Repository public key, fingerprint 6953FA0C6431F30347D65B03AF0CD687D51A6E63. Served at https://etherpad.org/key.asc after the next release. 3. `packaging/apt/generate-signing-key.sh` — one-shot helper that generated the keypair, kept for documented future rotation. 4. `packaging/README.md` — apt-repo install recipe is now the recommended path. ## Required secrets before the next tagged release Two secrets on ether/etherpad before the next `v*` tag push: - APT_SIGNING_KEY — ASCII-armoured private key for the Etherpad APT Repository keypair (long key id AF0CD687D51A6E63), generated with packaging/apt/generate-signing-key.sh. - SITE_DEPLOY_KEY — SSH private key. The public half registered as a deploy key with WRITE access on ether/ether.github.com. If either is missing the job fails fast with a clear error. ## What this PR does not change - The release job still attaches both versioned (etherpad_<v>_<arch>.deb) and stable-aliased (etherpad-latest_<arch>.deb) artefacts to the GitHub Release. Anyone pulling from releases/latest/download/etherpad-latest_amd64.deb keeps working. - The build-job smoke test (start under systemd, /health, purge) is unchanged. - docs.etherpad.org is untouched; this PR never pushes to gh-pages. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * ci(packaging): emit unindented Release headers + tighten artefact glob Two corrections from a fresh Qodo review of the rebased apt-publish job: 1. The dists/${SUITE}/Release heredoc was indented with the workflow's YAML scope, which means the resulting file had 10-space-prefixed field lines (` Origin: Etherpad`). apt parsers reject any leading whitespace on header fields per RFC 822 / Debian control format, so the entire suite would have failed to parse on `apt update` even before checksums were appended. Replace the heredoc with `printf '%s\n' ...` so the indentation is entirely under workflow control and impossible to break with a future YAML re-indent. 2. Tighten the artefact glob from `etherpad_*_amd64.deb` to `etherpad_[0-9]*_amd64.deb`. The hyphen-separator distinction (etherpad_<v>_… vs etherpad-latest_…) already kept the alias out of the array — Qodo's analysis of a duplicate-Packages bug was incorrect. But pinning to a leading-digit version segment makes the contract explicit and defends against any future alias that accidentally lands on `dist/etherpad_<word>_<arch>.deb`. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> |
||
|
|
c55007361c
|
chore: updated node to supported 22,24,25 (#7628)
* chore: updated node to supported 22,24,25 * chore: updated node to supported 22,24,25 * chore: updated node to supported 22,24,25 * chore: updated node to supported 22,24,25 * chore: upgrade deb * chore: upgrade dockerfile * chore: use explicit node * chore: use node 22 * chore: use node 22 |
||
|
|
0b40bfc784
|
feat(packaging): add Debian (.deb) build via nfpm with systemd unit (v2) (#7583)
* feat(packaging): add Debian (.deb) build via nfpm with systemd unit First-class Debian packaging for Etherpad, producing etherpad_<version>_<arch>.deb artefacts for amd64 and arm64 from a single nfpm manifest. Installing the package gives users: - /opt/etherpad with a prebuilt, self-contained node_modules/ — no pnpm required at runtime, just `nodejs (>= 20)`. - etherpad system user/group, created via `adduser` in preinst. - /etc/etherpad/settings.json seeded from the template on first install, preserved across upgrades, removed on `purge`. Seed rewrites dbType from the template's dev-only `dirty` default to `sqlite`, pointed at /var/lib/etherpad/etherpad.db so fresh installs get an ACID-safe DB without manual config. sqlite is shipped by ueberdb2 (rusty-store-kv), so no additional apt deps are needed. - /var/lib/etherpad owned by etherpad:etherpad, writable under the hardened unit's ProtectSystem=strict. - /lib/systemd/system/etherpad.service — hardened unit (NoNewPrivileges, ProtectSystem=strict, ProtectHome, PrivateTmp, RestrictAddressFamilies) with Restart=on-failure. - /usr/bin/etherpad CLI wrapper running `node --import tsx/esm`. CI (.github/workflows/deb-package.yml) triggers on v* tags, builds both arches via native runners (ubuntu-latest + ubuntu-24.04-arm), smoke-tests the amd64 package end-to-end (install → verify sqlite default → systemctl start → curl /health → purge → confirm user removed), and attaches the artefacts to the GitHub Release. Re-introduces the work from #7559 (reverted in #7582) with two corrections: 1. Package name and all installed paths use `etherpad`, not `etherpad-lite` — matches the repo rename. Kept replaces/conflicts on `etherpad-lite` so any dev builds of the reverted PR upgrade cleanly. 2. Default dbType is `sqlite`, not `dirty`. The template's own comment says dirty is for testing only; shipping it by default to everyone who runs `apt install etherpad` is the wrong tradeoff for a production package. Publishing to an APT repo (Cloudsmith, Launchpad PPA, self-hosted reprepro) is intentionally out of scope — needs a governance decision on who holds the signing key. Recipes are documented in packaging/README.md. Refs #7529, #7559, #7582 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(packaging): address PR review — startup crashes, supply chain, Node LTS Addresses Qodo and SamTV12345 review feedback on #7583: - postinstall: symlink /opt/etherpad/var → /var/lib/etherpad/var so ProtectSystem=strict doesn't block runtime writes (var/js, installed_plugins.json, etc.). Existing ReadWritePaths covers it. - postinstall: seed installed_plugins.json with ep_etherpad-lite so checkForMigration() does not spawn `pnpm ls` on first boot — pnpm is not a runtime dep, and the bundled node_modules already contains every shipped plugin. Prevents network plugin installs at first run. - postremove: clean up the new var symlink on remove. - workflow: verify nfpm .deb sha256 against upstream checksums.txt before sudo dpkg -i (defense in depth). - workflow: bump Node 22 → 24 (current LTS, per SamTV12345). The deb Depends stays at nodejs (>= 20) to match Etherpad's engines.node. - workflow: smoke-test now asserts the var symlink and seeded installed_plugins.json exist post-install. - workflow: publish stable etherpad-latest_{amd64,arm64}.deb aliases alongside the versioned files in the GitHub Release. - README: bump Node guidance to 24, document /releases/latest URL, link to engines.node floor. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(packaging): tsx CJS hook, plugin paths writable, glob tag triggers Addresses second-round Qodo review on #7583: - bin/etherpad: switch from `--import tsx/.../esm` to `--require tsx/cjs`. server.ts uses `exports.start = ...` which throws under the ESM loader; the prod script in src/package.json uses tsx/cjs for the same reason. - postinstall: symlink /opt/etherpad/src/plugin_packages → /var/lib/etherpad/plugin_packages and chgrp /opt/etherpad/src/node_modules to etherpad with mode 2775. Otherwise admin-UI plugin install EACCESes — those are the dirs LinkInstaller writes to. - systemd unit: add /opt/etherpad/src/node_modules to ReadWritePaths so symlink creation by the etherpad user is allowed under ProtectSystem=strict. plugin_packages is already covered via the symlink into /var/lib/etherpad. - postremove: clean up the new plugin_packages symlink on remove. - workflow: tag filters were `v[0-9]+.[0-9]+.[0-9]+`, but Actions tag filters are globs, not regex. `[0-9]+` matches one character, so multi-digit tags like v2.10.0 would never trigger. Switch to `v*.*.*` / `v*.*.*-*`, matching handleRelease.yml. - workflow smoke test now asserts plugin_packages symlink target, ownership of plugin_packages and node_modules. - test-local.sh: new script that builds the .deb and runs the same smoke test in a throwaway systemd-enabled Docker container, so failures are caught before pushing. - README: document test-local.sh. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore(packaging): test-local.sh — fix cgroups v2, add --no-systemd mode - systemd-in-docker on cgroups v2 needs --cgroupns=host and a writable /sys/fs/cgroup mount; the previous :ro version booted to nothing. - New --no-systemd mode: drops the systemd container in favour of plain ubuntu:24.04 + manual launch under the etherpad user. Validates the postinstall, wrapper, plugin paths, and /health without depending on the host's systemd-in-docker setup. Use it when --privileged systemd containers don't boot on your kernel/docker combo. - On systemd container exit the script now dumps the last 50 log lines and points at --no-systemd as the fallback. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore(packaging): test-local.sh — reuse cached image in --no-systemd If ubuntu:24.04 isn't on disk and the registry is unreachable, fall back to whichever ubuntu/debian image is already cached (e.g. the jrei/systemd-ubuntu image we pulled for the systemd path). Avoids a registry round-trip on flaky networks. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix: handle spawn errors in run_cmd; deb-package install order + offline-safe test src/node/utils/run_cmd.ts: Without `proc.on('error', ...)` a spawn failure (e.g. ENOENT for a missing binary) is emitted as an unlistened 'error' event, which Node treats as an uncaught exception that bypasses the awaiting try/catch and kills the process. The .deb hits this on first boot because plugins.ts spawns `pnpm --version` for a startup log line and pnpm isn't a runtime dep — Etherpad logs "Starting" then immediately stops. Reject the promise on 'error' so the existing try/catch in the caller actually catches it. packaging/scripts/postinstall.sh: chown /var/lib/etherpad/plugin_packages AFTER `cp -a` from the staged tree — `cp -a` preserves source (root) ownership and was re-rooting the directory we'd just chowned to etherpad. Same ordering the var symlink block already used. packaging/test-local.sh: Run `CI=1 pnpm install --frozen-lockfile` before staging so the package is built from a fresh, lockfile-consistent tree (matches CI). Fixes spurious "Cannot find module 'X'" failures from stale local symlinks pointing at out-of-date pnpm store paths. End-to-end test now passes: postinstall asserts pass, /health returns 200, dpkg --purge cleans up. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore: gitignore packaging build artefacts; drop accidental commit Drop packaging/etc/settings.json.dist that snuck into the previous commit (generated at build time by test-local.sh / CI from settings.json.template). Add /staging/, /dist/, /packaging/etc/ to .gitignore so they don't recur. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(plugins): downgrade missing-pnpm log from ERROR to debug The startup IIFE that logs the pnpm version is informational only. pnpm is a dev-only dependency: admin-UI plugin install goes through live-plugin-manager directly, and plugin migration is short-circuited when var/installed_plugins.json is present (e.g. on packaged installs). A missing pnpm on PATH is therefore expected on hardened deployments and shouldn't surface as a red ERROR in journalctl. Detect ENOENT specifically and log at debug; treat other errors (permission denied, etc.) as warnings. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(packaging): smoke deb on PRs + backend test for run_cmd spawn errors CI gap: deb-package.yml only fired on v* tag pushes, so a PR that broke the .deb wasn't caught until release time. Wire it to PRs and develop pushes via a paths filter covering packaging files and the runtime files Etherpad needs at first boot. The release job already gates on `if: startsWith(github.ref, 'refs/tags/v')` so PR runs won't try to publish. Test gap: the run_cmd.ts spawn-error fix (commit |
||
|
|
de5feb2eb5
|
Revert "feat(packaging): add Debian (.deb) build via nfpm with systemd unit (…" (#7582)
This reverts commit
|
||
|
|
6bb879ed03
|
feat(packaging): add Debian (.deb) build via nfpm with systemd unit (#7559)
* feat(packaging): add Debian (.deb) build via nfpm with systemd unit First-class Debian packaging for Etherpad, producing signed-ready etherpad-lite_<version>_<arch>.deb artefacts for amd64 and arm64 from a single nfpm manifest. Installing the package gives users: - /opt/etherpad-lite with a prebuilt, self-contained node_modules/ — no pnpm required at runtime, just `nodejs (>= 20)`. - etherpad system user/group, created via `adduser` in preinst. - /etc/etherpad-lite/settings.json seeded from the template on first install, preserved across upgrades, removed on `purge`. - /var/lib/etherpad-lite owned by etherpad:etherpad, with the default dirty-DB retargeted there so ProtectSystem=strict works. - /lib/systemd/system/etherpad-lite.service — hardened unit (NoNewPrivileges, ProtectSystem=strict, ProtectHome, PrivateTmp, RestrictAddressFamilies) with Restart=on-failure. - /usr/bin/etherpad-lite CLI wrapper running `node --import tsx/esm`. CI (.github/workflows/deb-package.yml) triggers on v* tags, builds both arches via native runners (ubuntu-latest + ubuntu-24.04-arm), smoke-tests the amd64 package end-to-end (install → systemctl start → curl /health → purge → confirm user removed), and attaches the artefacts to the GitHub Release. Publishing to an APT repo (Cloudsmith, Launchpad PPA, self-hosted reprepro) is intentionally out of scope — needs a governance decision on who holds the signing key. Recipes are documented in packaging/README.md. Refs #7529 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(deb): fail smoke test on /health timeout, tighten default-file perms, 2-space indent Addresses Qodo review feedback on #7559: 1. Smoke test false-positive: the `for` loop polling /health never failed the job if the endpoint stayed down — `curl && break || sleep 2` keeps returning 0 from the trailing `sleep`, so `set -e` never trips. CI could attach a broken .deb to a release. Fix: track success explicitly and exit 1 (plus dump journald logs for diagnostics) when the service never becomes healthy. 2. /etc/default/etherpad-lite was world-readable (0644). systemd loads it via `EnvironmentFile=…`, and Etherpad supports ${ENV_VAR}-substitution for secrets (DB_PASSWORD etc.), so any local user could read anything admins drop there. Fix: install the conffile as root:etherpad 0640 — only root and the service user can read it. 3. Indentation: reflow maintainer scripts from 4-space to 2-space to match the repo style rule. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> |